John Childs confessed to six murders. There were no bodies. There was a meat mincer, a fireplace in a council flat in Poplar, and a confession so detailed and so cold that experienced detectives were shaken by it. Years later he said he had made it all up, that he had never killed anyone and that the police had fed him the details, and two of the men he helped send down for life eventually walked free because of it. The truth may be worse than either story: he was both a chilling contract killer and one of the most convincing liars the British courts have seen.
A quiet man
John Henry Childs was born in December 1938, a boy from a broken home, raised by foster parents who he later said treated him harshly. By 14 he was in front of magistrates, and by 19 he was in Borstal.
Childs was never a public hard man, a face in the pubs or a name in the gossip columns. He kept his head down, and his reputation came later, from what he claimed to have done in private.
The toy factory
Childs said he met McKenney and Pinfold in the late 1960s through Pinfold's toy factory in Dagenham, a building that made plastic ducks and children's toys. He claimed they eventually realised there was money to be made killing to order.
The first to die, in Childs's account, was Terrence Eve, a business partner of Pinfold's. Childs said he and McKenney killed him at the factory because Pinfold wanted him gone. Then came the part at the centre of his confession. He took the body back to his flat in Poplar. He had bought a meat mincer for the purpose. It was not powerful enough, so he tried cutting the body up, and when that failed too he burned it, piece by piece, in his own fireplace. This was not panic. It was method.
In 1975, according to Childs, a man called Leonard Thompson paid £1,800 to have a neighbour and rival, George Brett, killed. Childs told police they lured Brett to the same factory, but Brett did not come alone. He brought his ten-year-old son. In Childs's account, both were shot dead with a Sten gun, taken back to the flat in Poplar, dismembered and burned in the same fireplace.
Then came Robert Brown, who lived at the factory and, Childs said, had seen too much. He was lured to the flat, where, in the confession, McKenney shot him and Childs stabbed him. The fifth, Frederick Sherwood, was said to be a £4,000 contract from a man called Paul Morton Thirtle, also known as Paul Hammond. The sixth was Ronald Andrews, a friend of McKenney's, killed, Childs said, because McKenney was having an affair with his wife. They drove Andrews's car into the River Nene in Lincolnshire to make it look like an accident. Police did not believe it, and the story began to unravel.
July 1979
Childs was already in custody for an unrelated robbery when detectives sat him down in July 1979 to talk about McKenney. By the end of the day he was talking about all of it: names, dates, addresses and methods. Then he wanted two things: protection for his family, and a deal. He believed that giving evidence would mean serving something like eight years.
In December 1979 Childs pleaded guilty at the Old Bailey to all six murders and was sentenced to life, with no minimum term recommended because he was due to give evidence for the Crown. In 1980 McKenney was convicted of four of the murders and Pinfold of the murder of Terrence Eve. But there was no eight years. Childs was going to die in prison, and once he understood that, the story began to change.
The retractions
By the mid-1980s he was saying he had made it all up and that McKenney and Pinfold were innocent. In the late 1990s, around a possible book deal, he confessed all over again, and to more: a killing at Rochester Borstal in the 1950s, a murder at a Holloway club linked to the Krays, a vagrant dismembered in Poplar High Street. Police investigated and found nothing. Some of the men he said were dead were alive. Some of the crimes had never happened.
In 2003 the Court of Appeal looked again at the case against McKenney and Pinfold. It had heard what kind of man Childs was: a liar, a man who could fabricate when it suited him. It found his evidence against them so unreliable it was worthless, and their convictions were quashed. Both men walked free.
That did not free Childs. In 2014, when he challenged his own convictions, the Court of Appeal accepted that he had narcissistic personality disorder, that he met the threshold for psychopathy and that he had lied. It did not accept that his own guilty pleas were unsafe. In the court's view he had confessed because he believed it served his purpose, and changed the story when the deal did not come.
There is no clean ending: no bodies, only a man who lied and craved importance, and a court asked whether his lies made him innocent. Its answer was that they did not clear him. They exposed him. The victims' families have never had full closure.