London Underworld · Episode 5 of 11

Roy Shaw, Pat Tate and the Pub Fight

14 min · For Supporters

The story goes that Roy Shaw hit Pat Tate with a left and a right, broke his jaw and knocked him spark out. The rumour has done the rounds since the mid to late 1990s, and it turned up again in a book on Shaw done with his son. Two of the hardest men in the south-east, one punch-up outside a pub. Did it happen, or is it a myth?

Pat Tate

Pat Tate was one of the Essex Boys, a name the press gave them that they never used themselves. The others were Tony Tucker, whose security firm supplied doormen across Essex and Southend, and Craig Rolfe. All three were shot dead in horrific circumstances, and the film puts it in 1998. Two men were charged with the murders. Both denied it, and the argument over who really did it still runs in true crime groups to this day.

Tate was six foot two and 18 stone, built like a Weetabix box, and on the juice. He was a powerful and violent man. A man who says he was there describes Tate stabbing a prisoner with a bottle in Swaleside and throwing him over the balcony.

Then there was the Happy Eater. His partner had phoned for food and argued with the man in the restaurant over what she was getting. Tate grabbed the phone and told him to give her what she wanted or get smashed up. The man told him where to go and hung up, not realising who he was dealing with. Tate turned up, battered him and took money. He was up in court for it in 1988, chinned the guards, ran out, jumped on the back of a motorbike and escaped, and spent a spell in Spain before he was caught and jailed. People who knew him say he was a good guy before the drugs took hold. Nobody says he could not fight.

Roy Shaw

Roy Shaw was a legend. He was around when the Krays were active, closer to Ronnie than to Reggie. He could box, and enjoyed it, but he was a criminal first. An armed robbery got him around 18 years, and he fought the system every step of the way. The famous story is that he punched his way out of a cell. The true version, the film says, is that he ripped off a piece of metal and smashed his way out. He fought the screws constantly, was carted off to Dartmoor when they could not control him, and was given the liquid cosh, which may have damaged him later on. A visit from another big gangster of the day told him to behave or he would never get out.

He got out, the film believes, around 1978. Then came the bare-knuckle and unlicensed fights, including the three with Lenny McLean. A man who trained him back then says Shaw, by then around 40, was a good boxer, not tall but stocky and powerfully built, and kept himself in shape. He made his real money as a shrewd businessman in property and cars, not from fighting.

The rumour

The version going round goes like this. Shaw was out one night with a couple of women. He liked a drink and liked a night out. In a bar, the story says somewhere in Essex, a big man he did not know was drinking with a few mates. It was supposedly Pat Tate. Tate is alleged to have grabbed one of the women, or tried to chat her up, or been rude in some way. Shaw was not having that on his watch.

Words were exchanged and they went outside. Tate was said to have three or four men with him. Bang, a left and a right, and Tate was out of it. His mates bottled it. His jaw, the story says, was broken. End of story.

Asking around

We went looking. The two men who first passed the story on could not give a name or a year, and neither was there. So we asked people from the Essex Boys era who worked the doors and knew the firm, and older men who were Shaw's friends from the same area.

Around 90% of them had never heard the rumour, and had never heard Shaw tell it. Only a handful had. The man behind the book done with Shaw's son had heard it too, but when he asked the Shaw family, they had never heard of it either.

So the film turns to the dates. The film puts Tate's birth in '54. Once he was out of prison and alongside Tony Tucker, he was a known face, and a story like that would have gone through Essex and London like wildfire. If it happened at all, when could it have happened? And there is a half-remembered account of Shaw decking a big, unnamed man in a pub that might explain the whole thing.

Did Roy Shaw really knock out Pat Tate, or did somebody put two and two together? The film gives its verdict.

Previous: Canning Town and the ICF v Millwall

Next: Ronnie O'Sullivan Sr and the Murder of the Krays' Driver

More from London Underworld