Eighty football lads walked into a freshly refitted Blackpool bar in the summer of '88 and started taking their clothes off. They were changing for a night out. The men in the bar did not see it that way, and within 20 minutes the place was a blood-spattered pigsty.
This is the clash between Stoke City's Naughty Forty and Blackpool's Steve Sinclair, told twice: once by the Stoke lads, once by Sinclair himself. The two stories do not agree.
The stag do
Picture it. Eighty or so casuals, with a few local lunatics mixed in, on their way from Stoke-on-Trent to the sunny shores of Blackpool for one of the lads' stag do. A sure recipe for mayhem. The beer and the banter flowed, the lads swapped war stories and boasts, and the driver pulled up at a boozer called the Number Three club so they could have a few liveners and get changed.
The Number Three had just had a million-pound makeover. The lads were game and comfortable with violence, average age about 22, and they were a serious force.
The Stoke version
According to the Naughty Forty's own history, the book Naughty, the 80 lads poured in wearing casual clobber, with bags over their shoulders holding their club clothes: trousers, shirts, shoes. The plush furnishings were not improved by red-eyed football hooligans walking round in their pants.
The men in suits, the Stoke lads say, took umbrage, started picking up bags and tried to throw people out. One Stoke lad picked up a fire extinguisher and started spraying them. The book calls them penguins, bodybuilding hard men in their mid-30s who were not about to be intimidated by a bunch of 22-year-olds, however many there were.
About a dozen of them fought 80 lads in a drawn-out bar brawl of Wild West proportions. Everything was flying. One huge man was decking anybody who came within arm's length. It turned out he was in charge of most of the doors and bouncers in Blackpool.
When the police started arriving, everybody fled in different directions to cut the chance of arrest. A few were caught.
Dixieland
About 30 or 40 of them ended up at the Dixieland nightclub, sitting in the shadows of a back room the size of two pubs. Then another mob came out of the main room. They were Leeds. There was a freeze-frame moment, and then the fighting erupted. Girls screamed and ran in every direction to escape flying glasses and stray punches as the battle ran through the club, until the police arrived and let the dogs loose on both mobs.
The Sinclair version
Steve Sinclair's book tells a different story. He met three friends at the Number Three at about seven o'clock and stood at the end of the long main bar, having a quiet drink. The pub was busy with couples and nice people when a large team of lads came in. There must have been 50 of them, he says, loud and boisterous from the moment they arrived, and within moments the regulars were uncomfortable.
The licensee had no door staff on, because usually there was no need. He knew Sinclair and his friend were in nightclubs and security, and asked them to keep an eye on things while he phoned the police. There was not a lot they could do, Sinclair told him, but okay.
Two minutes later one of the group set off a fire extinguisher, spraying water over the customers in an arc that sent people running and diving under tables. Sinclair and his friend were suited and booted for work, in boss suits and shiny shoes. The jet caught Sinclair at waist height. He did not flinch. He just stared. So the lad came back and sprayed him up and down, laughing all the time.
Sinclair put his pint down on the bar and flew at him. He took a blow to the chest from the extinguisher and did not feel it. By his account he picked the lad up, ran him straight through his pals and carried him the full width of the pub into a small annex bar, with his friend right behind him keeping the others off his back.
He slammed the lad down and was about to let him have a few right hands when a searing pain hit his left eye. A glass or a bottle, thrown by one of the lad's pals. He shook his head to clear his vision and saw he was spraying blood everywhere.
He looked down. The lad on the floor was smiling at him.
Two sides, one fight
So who was telling the truth? Was it a dozen bouncers in penguin suits against 80, or a handful of men having a quiet drink against 50? What did Sinclair do next, what happened when the blue lights arrived, and how did one of the Stoke lads end up working the doors with him years later? The film puts both accounts side by side and gives its view.